Winchendon Courier · winchendoncourier.com
The Winchendon Courier
Serving the community since 1878
An Independent Community Newspaper
Show alerts (1)
Local News

BOS Approve New Contract for Town Manager

Winchendon's pay scale still well below local average for comparable positions

evaluation for Justin Sultzbach
evaluation for Justin Sultzbach

Esta noticia todavía se está traduciendo; aquí está en inglés.

Listen · Read aloud; the words light up as you listen

In this informational material provided at the March 28, meeting of the BOS regarding Town Manager contract negotiations, individual assessments over ten categories can be viewed as given by each Selectman on the Board. Of note is a large disparity in scores regarding "Relations with Elected Board Members" which also coincided with the only no-vote regarding the new contract. Selectman Barbara Anderson also provided the lowest score in every category, of all scores submitted as presented by the BOS at the public meeting. Public record, Town of Winchendon

After convening more than one executive session devoted to contract negotiations, at their regular meeting on Monday, March 28 the Board of Selectmen voted to modify Town Manager Justin Sultzbach's contract based on his performance to date, and to set a salary closer to the competitive rate for the field.

The original contract which was effective May 17, 2021 through June 30, 2024, established a starting salary of $130,000 annually plus benefits, based on experience. It was Sultzbach's first official position as a Town Manager and he needed to prove he could do the job. Since then, Sultzbach has demonstrated competence through aggressive future capital planning, seeking grant funding opportunities both on his own and with town assistance, budget management on his own and with town assistance, and other required facets of the position. The Board, by a vote of 4-1, approved increasing Sultzbach's base salary to $139,050, with the only no vote cast by Selectman Barbara Anderson.

Sultzbach told the Courier that after the pay raise, he still earns $16,000 less annually than what his predecessor Keith Hickey would have been making at this point. With standard annual increases, had Hickey continued as Winchendon's Town Manager, his salary would have been set at $155,086 by 2023.

Additional benefits such as regular paid holidays, sick days, bereavement leave, and four weeks paid vacation continue as specified in the original contract, as does a "Phone and Vehicle Stipend." The stipend, which Sultzbach explained was previously $3,600 for his predecessor, is now $4,300, as adjusted 2.5 percent annually over the years 2015 to 2023.

One of the dilemmas facing many municipalities in finding and keeping qualified professional staff is that the private sector pays much more competitively than the public sector. Due to this, many cities and towns in Massachusetts struggle to find and keep qualified Town Managers and Town Administrators, forcing most municipalities to offer a higher pay to qualified candidates. A Google search on "Much closer to Sultzbach's home" shows that Carlisle, MA is advertising for a Town Adminstrator at $170K plus; a search on "Sultzbach's home town" shows that Lowell, MA is advertising for a City Manager at a salary of $195,000 to $235,000 annually. The local town of Lancaster, at half the commute for Sultzbach, was advertising recently for a Town Manager at $160,000 to start. Even the small western Massachusetts town of Williamstown, with a population of just 7,800, is seeking a Town Manager at a starting pay of $140,000 to $155,000. It's easy to see the competitive salary problem in finding and keeping qualified professional staff. At $130K, Winchendon was offering far below the competitive pay rate. Communities that don't offer competitive pay risk seeing a high turnover in highly qualified staff.

At the March 28 meeting, the BOS began discussion and voting on the topic of "Consideration of ratification of the new Town Manager's Contract" at 2:35:30 into the meeting. The recorded meeting can be viewed online at Winchendon Board of Selectmen Meeting March 28, 2022 .

Board Chair Audrey LaBrie acknowledged that since coming on board, Sultzbach had helped the town obtain some $1,750,000 in grants so far for fiscal year 2022. Many of these were team efforts where Sultzbach contributed his input. She added that Sultzbach had also personally landed three additional grants for a total of $127,000 to date and is currently working on further grants. By working with the Robinson Broadhurst Foundation, Sultzbach secured an additional $600K for the Winchendon Community Park Amphitheater, LaBrie pointed out, and also negotiated health care cost percentages resulting in a $20,000 savings for the next fiscal year for the town.

LaBrie explained, "There was a lot of discussion about it's a tight budget. It's always a tight budget. The comment was made by multiple members about the current employment situation, the need for qualified people at various levels, and the need for the town to ensure that we can keep [people] that we feel are good for Winchendon, and at the same time balancing that with the bottom line numbers. The amount of savings that Mr. Sultzbach has brought in, as a majority, the board felt that it was more than offset of the $9,750 of the additional costs." Selectman Danielle LaPointe responded to LaBrie, "You've done a very good job with your synopsis."

A vote was taken to approve the updated Town Manager's contract which passed by 4-1. Sultzbach thanked the Board, saying, "I would like to express my appreciation of support from the majority of the board, it's definitely appreciated. I think this community has definitely done its job expressing its hopes for the future. I think seeing historically where Winchendon was and where Winchendon could be, I think it's special for me to be a part of that, and I think it's special for the community, so thank you."

The Courier met with Sultzbach on Wednesday, April 6, to clarify the points in the new versus the old contract. Asked what he would like to say to town residents regarding his continued employment with the community, Sultzbach said, "I would really like to thank the Board of Selectman and the citizens of Winchendon for their continued support. I think we came to agreement on a contract that was both competitive to the market, but also fair to the community. I think that was an important piece. In addition, I am always thanking the community for the opportunity to serve this town. I think there are a lot of good things we have coming down the road, and their continued support is appreciated."

A name wrong in this story? Tell us
A figure wrong in this story? Tell us
Who is in this picture?help name the people in it

Know someone in the picture? Sign in to tell the editors — no password, a link by email.

Comments

0 so far
No comments yet. Be the first.

Sign up to comment

Your name shows with your comments; your email never does. We send one email — tap it and you are back here, signed in, ready to comment. No password.

Comments from signed-up readers appear at once. No links. Off-topic, spam and abusive comments are taken down. Already signed up? Sign in.