Citizens Raise Questions About Superintendent Hiring Process for the 2024-25 School Year
Esta notícia ainda está sendo traduzida; aqui está em inglês.
At the School Committee meeting on Tuesday, May 7 (postponed from its usual Thursday day and time), several citizens expressed questions and concerns about the process involved in extending current Interim Superintendent Dr. Ruthann Goguen's contract another year, when the position had been posted as open and references were made in the agenda to a "superintendent search." In the following discussions, Committee Chair Karen Kast attempted to clarify and explain the situation, saying the Committee had voted to extend Dr. Goguen's contract on January 18, 2024.
Resident Michael Barbaro, who had just been elected the day before as a write-in candidate for a seat on the School Committee (his term will begin after Annual Town Meeting), rose first. "I'm looking at the agenda this evening. And I have some questions and more of a concern...further down on the agenda, you have a superintendent search discussion, having never seen a search committee formed, or interviews planned. And then seeing later on, further on down, the line going into an Executive Session. I'm trying to understand that, because Karen, one of the things you did say was being fair and transparent. Without a superintendent search, without a committee, if you vote for an extension on a superintendent without even talking to anybody else, that's not fair and transparent. And it's never been done." Citizens in the audience interrupted him with applause.
Mr. Barbaro continued that even if they wanted to keep the current Superintendent, "It's a process. To me, what it looks like is the process is being jumped. And with only three members here this evening, and not the other two members. Again, this is not a full Board. I urge you not to make any decisions on the Superintendent until a full Board is set. There are certain requirements and you're not following them."
Ms. Kast responded, saying that "the term 'superintendent search' is a misnomer on this agenda. The decision was made January 18." The Committee at that time "had a discussion by the full Board to either do a superintendent search, which would have involved bringing in MASC or one of the other search groups and doing a full superintendent search, which would have been much more comprehensive than us just posting a job posting, or extending the Interim Superintendent." A motion was made and seconded to extend the Superintendent's contract for another year, she explained, but because Dr. Goguen is retired, they will need to ask for a waiver for her to continue working in the position. Part of this is a requirement by the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE) that the position be posted.
"We did not vote for a superintendent search in this body," she said. "And that was never the intent of this body. This body voted to do an extension of the Interim Superintendent." She urged those present to watch the video of the meeting in question, saying the minutes were not yet available but the video was.
Resident Kim Chambers, a teacher at Toy Town Elementary, rose to say that she had seen the announcement of the vacant position of Superintendent of Schools for the 24-25 school year, posted on March 13, 2024. "All of the requirements for successful candidates are listed. There is a place to submit applications, from what I understand we got over a dozen. Completed application must be received before April 15. The appointment will be made in May 2024. You just said the appointment was already made in January. So I'm wondering why a posting went out from you, which I believe is a legal posting, saying that the appointment would be made in May of 2024, if you did it in January."
Later in the meeting, the Committee returned to the topic, after discussing related issues including the $180,000 severance package paid to former Superintendent Thad King, and Open Meeting Law complaints over the lack of meeting minutes being available in a timely fashion (the most recent School Committee minutes posted on the town website are August 23, 2023, and neither minutes, video nor audio recordings for the meeting in which two Committee members including the Chair walked out are available).
Ms. Kast reiterated that the Committee had voted to extend Dr. Goguen's contract, but because of the rules of the state retirement system about maximum number of hours Dr. Goguen could work, they had to apply for a waiver. The application period for a waiver opens on May 1. "We had to post for superintendents, to see if anybody applied that might be of the same caliber, and with the same skill sets, and so on and so forth. So we did as required by the waiver paperwork," she explained.
Committee Vice Chair David LaPointe said, "We as the school committee, we don't have a lot of power, by the way. And one of the things we do have is the appointment of a superintendent. So we take that very seriously. And we don't just make it off the cuff. And we just don't vote for somebody because we vote for somebody. So we had to pull this information together on these applicants. And we looked at these applicants, there were 14. And you have to look at their qualifications." Dr. Goguen was one of the applicants, she had to apply for the position.
Of the 14 applicants, only two had any experience as a Superintendent, Mr. LaPointe said. One of them was Dr. Goguen. "She's heads and shoulders above all the others," he said. But he emphasized that this is not just the Committee's decision. DESE will review all the applicants as part of determining whether to grant a waiver for Dr. Goguen. The position is still Interim Superintendent. Next year, Mr. LaPointe said, they'll start a search in the fall, before many candidates are locked into contracts. "Right now, there's not a lot out there" for applicants, he said. Mr. LaPointe also emphasized that staff in the schools, and parents, expressed a lot of confidence in and support for Dr. Goguen. "What we don't want to do is start over again, this summer, and have somebody come in who is not qualified, or who isn't happy, or doesn't have the qualifications and the skills that Dr. Goguen has, so that we'll be doing an injustice to our students. I'm completely convinced of that," he said.
Committee member Jake Catlin chimed in, "I agree with everything that you've said there. And you just look at what Dr. Goguen brings to the table and what she's done in the short time that she's had here. And really jumping in practically as the school year was starting. I'm no administrator, I'm just a dairy farmer. But I can only imagine what that entailed and to get the amount of things done. You look at, she has over six times the superintendent experience than anyone who applied here, it's not even close." The Committee wasn't doing anything "shady" as one speaker had suggested, no "backroom deal," he said.
Ms. Kast said that they will probably start the search process for the following year in August or September, and follow all the procedures with a search committee and involvement by all stakeholders, such as teachers, staff, parents and the community as a whole. "I think that is extremely important," she said. "And as much as I would have liked to have seen that done this year, because of just one thing after another, and because we are getting our feet back on the ground after such a fiasco last year, that could not be done. So I apologize if people are disappointed that we did not do that now. But if we had tried to do that between January and now, we would not have been able to do it." She wanted everyone in the audience "to be involved 100 percent."
Resident Lisa Tenney asked if the Committee was really getting input from the teachers and staff working in the schools with the children. "Yes, everything looks great on paper," she said, "come into the school rooms, talk to the teachers."
Ms. Kast reiterated that the decision had actually been made in January, and not at this meeting. The Committee now needed to approve continuing with the waiver application process. There was always the chance, Mr. LaPointe had said, that DESE would turn the waiver application down.
For those who are interested, the January 18 School Committee meeting video is up on Winchendon TV and may be viewed at https://winchendon.cablecast.tv/CablecastPublicSite/show/54?site=1 . The agenda for that meeting is at https://www.townofwinchendon.com/sites/g/files/vyhlif8401/f/agendas/sc_1.18.2024_amended_agenda.pdf and the topic is Agenda Item 9(c), "Superintendent Path Forward Discussion." The discussion begins at 1:03:20 on the video and is less than nine minutes long. At the time of the January 18 meeting, the first draft school district budget for FY2025 had not yet been completed.

Comments