FinCom Votes Not to Recommend STM Articles Addressing Water and Wastewater Enterprise Fund Deficits
Esta notícia ainda está sendo traduzida; aqui está em inglês.
In their meeting on October 12, the Winchendon Finance Committee voted unanimously, 6-0, not to recommend Warrant Articles 7 and 8, which request that funds be appropriated from Free Cash to cover anticipated deficits in the Water and Wastewater Enterprise Funds, respectively, for Fiscal Year 2022, which ends June 30, 2022. In their lengthy discussion, no mention was made of the rate increases charged to water and sewer users for the past two years.
(For previous Courier coverage of the water and wastewater budget shortfalls and rate increases, see: "Consulting Firm Addresses Growing Deficits in Water and Sewer Budgets" in the June 25-July 2 2020 edition of The Winchendon Courier along with Water and Sewer Rate Study Recommends Rate Increases on the town website, with links to the rate study and PowerPoint presentation by Wright Pierce Environmental Services; "Board of Selectmen Approve Water and Sewer Rate Increases for FY2022" in the March 25-April 1 2021 edition of The Winchendon Courier; "Town Accountant Updates BOS: Water/Sewer Hemorrhaging Dollars and Gallons" in the August 12-19 2021 edition of The Winchendon Courier) Finance Committee Chair Thomas Kane began the discussion with a detailed summary of the issues behind the four articles dealing with FY21 and FY22 shortfalls in the funds. "We could see this coming at the end of year last year. I remember we noted that there was a shortfall in user payments of, I don't remember what it was, one hundred thirty-forty thousand dollars. There was some savings in expenses that offset it to some extent, then this eighty thousand dollar gap was there...My first thought, I remember asking this question back in July, was it because people were not paying their water bills, because of financial hardships due to COVID. But I was told that actually the collection rate is very good right now with the water and the sewer bills."
Mr. Kane went on to talk about the possibility that the meters were inaccurate, and the fact that there is considerable known leakage from the pipes throughout the system. He pointed out that Enterprise Funds, by their nature and definition, are intended to be self-sustaining and balanced, but Winchendon has been carrying over excess retained earnings from previous years to cover an increasing shortfall each year, and now this has run out.
"But we haven't taken the obvious step, it seems to me, to deal with it," Mr. Kane said. "There may be fixes to improve recordings of the amount of cubic feet that go into the homes, and make that more accurate, and leaks that we can fix. But it would look as though we were subsidizing the rates with retained earnings for years, and we're reluctant to raise the rates, I don't understand why we would be reluctant to increase our rates."
Town Manager Justin Sultzbach responded "And I think it's an important question to ask and an important discussion to have as a community. I think you touched on a lot of important points there, it's very much a multi-faceted issue. I think the reason any time this conversation comes up, the first things you hear about is the rates, is because the rates are so [important] a component, and it's something that needs to be reviewed." He added, "Another issue is long-standing capital issues that have, frankly, not been addressed for ten or twenty years. The water meters is an excellent example of there, where our then-new DPW Director attempted to take the initiative to replave water meters so that we could more accurately track how much water was being utilized by residents and unfortunately that was voted down on Town [Meeting] floor."
Mr. Sultzbach went on to talk about issues with the aging pipes and facilities, and the possibility of using American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funding to help pay for repairs and upgrades.
FinCom member Dr. Maureen Ward said, "You've addressed the aging and the failure to keep up, but you haven't addressed that this town has failed to increase the water rates for years. When I look at [Articles] 7 and 8, you're asking us to pay forward for what you anticipate as a loss without increasing the rates to try and mitigate some of that. So you're asking people that don't have wastewater, and don't have town water, to pay for those that have used it. I do have a problem with that. Because if we're using the water, increase our rates, so that we are self-sufficient, it's an Enterprise fund, it's supposed to be a wash. It's not supposed to cost us more. So if we're not doing our job by keeping our rates in line with our needs, that's our fault."
In response to questions by new FinCom member Adrian Guerrero, Department of Public Works Director Brian Croteau and Mr. Sultzbach explained that most repairs to broken pipes were handled in-house, if they were emergency situations, contracted out if they were large jobs, or handled by the private company running the two facilities, if the issues were at the plants.
Mr. Kane said, "We all know that we have overestimated the amount of money that we'd collect from users, consistently comes up short, never addressed it through increases in the rates. Nobody wants to pay three dollars a gallon for gas, but that's the price of gas. There aren't any gas stations surrounding us, oh, that's awfully high, I think we'll just charge two fifty. But that's what we do in this town with the water and sewer rates. We don't want to increase the rates, so we take a deficit. It's an Enterprise fund. It's got to operate on a break-even basis. And refusing to increase rates and going to the town's Free Cash is just no way to answer. We can't undo what we did last year, but I don't see why we should continue this by taking Free Cash now for a deficit that we won't know what the total is until July first."
When the FinCom voted on their recommendations, Dr. Ward made the motions not to approve Article 7 and Article 8. Both motions to not recommend passed unanimously, 6-0.
At the 2019 Fall Special Town Meeting, voters approved borrowing $1 million from the Water and Wastewater Enterprise funds--$550,000 from Water and $450,000 from Wastewater--to cover costs of replacing the water and sewer mains during the Central Street Reconstruction Project. This has not been mentioned in subsequent discussions of the Water and Wastewater Enterprise Funds. (See "Winchendon voters defeat article for expanded fire station," vote on Warrant Article 3, in the October 31-November 7 2019 edition of The Winchendon Courier .)

Comments