Town Hall Gets Visited by "First Amendment Auditor"
Esta noticia todavía se está traduciendo; aquí está en inglés.
Winchendon joined the ranks of the numerous municipalities to be visited by a "First Amendment Auditor" on Monday, December 19. Wearing a "gaiter" pulled up over their lower face and nose, and a cap or hood pulled down over their forehead, an individual of unknown name and indeterminate gender or nationality strolled around the offices in Town Hall for about 20 to 30 minutes, according to Acting Director of Planning and Development Nicole Roberts. The "auditor" carried a cell phone on a selfie stick and videorecorded everywhere they went.
Ms. Roberts and Town Manager's Executive Assistant Mary Calandrella reported that the "auditor" was pleasant and polite, asking for business cards for each staff person. They asked to talk to Town Manager Justin Sultzbach, but Mr. Sultzbach was not in his office at the time. They seemed to have a sweet tooth, taking a piece of complimentary candy from the bowl on the counter in several offices. Before or after visiting Town Hall, the "auditor" reportedly visited the police station and videorecorded in the lobby.
"We knew what he was" when they saw the "auditor," Ms. Roberts said, adding that all the offices were immediately notified that the "auditor" was on the premises.
Citizens have a legal right "to record anything in plain view, subject to time, place and manner restrictions" in any public place where they are legally allowed to be. "First amendment audits" purportedly test this right, and have been common for some fifteen years. In practice, as reported by the Washington Post in 2019 , auditing "has morphed into a YouTube subculture, with self-styled 'auditors' in many major U.S. cities roaming into suburbs and small towns to see how police react to a camera lens."
When "auditors" get a hostile reaction (or any reaction) from their video subjects, they post the video to YouTube channels which are monetized and often have thousands of followers. "Auditing" can be a highly lucrative hobby. Some "auditors" are basically Internet trolls in real life, hoping only to provoke a reaction that they can then ridicule on YouTube. This can create extremely unpleasant situations for town officials (Google "first amendment audits Massachusetts" to see some of these videos). The Massachusetts Municipal Association is hosting a free webinar for appointed and elected officials on "1st Amendment audit protocols" on January 10. ( Click here for details )
Mr. Sultzbach praised Town Hall staff for handling the situation with grace. "It's a fairly common occurrence. If the staff are well-trained, nothing comes of it. But I have heard of horror stories in other communities," he said via text message. "Proud of our people, as always."

Comments