School Committee Votes on Interim Superintendent after Multiplatform Interview Marathon
Cet article est en cours de traduction ; le voici en anglais.
After a 4-hour interview marathon with both Zoom and in-person meetings on Wednesday, August 2, the Winchendon School Committee voted to offer the position to candidate Dr. Ruthann Petruno-Goguen ( resume ) ( LinkedIn ), contingent on their accepting the position and all negotiations being successfully completed. Dr. Petruno-Goguen was the first interviewee and joined the Zoom meeting from Portugal, where she was traveling with her husband when she learned of the position posting.
With the school year scheduled to begin on Friday, August 25 with Professional Development days for staff, and students due to be back in class on Wednesday, August 30 (see academic calendar for 2023-2024 at https://www.winchendonk12.org/article/1159070 ), speed was of the essence for the School Committee to hire an interim Superintendent. The School Committee itself is down by two members following last week's unexpected departures by long-time member Greg Vine and former Chair Dr. Ryan Forsythe. The interim Superintendent position was posted with a four day window for applications, and appeared on the national public school systems jobs board SchoolSpring. School Committee Chair Karen Kast-McBride told the Courier that the Committee received a dozen applications, and winnowed them down to the top four finalists.
On Tuesday, August 1, the school district announced that interviews would take place on Wednesday, August 2 and would be open to the public. Beginning at 3:00 p.m. Dr. Petruno-Goguen and applicant Dr. Marlene A. DiLeo were interviewed via Zoom. Following that, the School Committee and interested members of the public assembled in the Town Hall 2nd floor auditorium for in-person interviews with applicants Shauna B. LaPointe and Roland R. Joyal, Jr. beginning at about 5:30 p.m. Following those interviews, the floor was opened for public comment. The Committee deliberated and voted on a candidate publicly, and then shooed citizens out of the auditorium so they could enter Executive Session and discuss details.
Dr. Forsythe, who had not yet submitted a formal letter of resignation, attended all the interviews and participated in the discussion but abstained from the final vote. He attended the second two interviews via a Zoom link to the auditorium, as he was away with his family. After last week's recording failure, Town Manager's administrative assistant Debra Dennis had two recording systems running for the in-person interviews, and multiple citizens in the auditorium were recording, as well.
After some brief technical glitches were overcome, Dr. Petruno-Goguen began her Zoom interview. "I am a retired superintendent," she explained. "I recently retired from the Webster Public Schools and I've been a superintendent for the last 12 years in three different districts, and I have been in public education for the past 23 years. I actually grew up in Jaffrey New Hampshire not far from Winchendon. So I'm familiar with the Winchendon community from a distance." She said that she had been on vacation and had gotten a call about the position being open. "Because it's close, because I'm a change agent and able to really set up systems and structures, I threw in my hat and so I'm here to answer any questions, and I'm eager to learn a little bit more about your community. And I see that with the interest online [some 20 citizens had joined the Zoom meeting] that people are very eager to have a leader in your district that's there to listen and help you come over the hump that you're in."
Asked what attracted her to the job, Dr. Petruno-Goguen said, "I have always been drawn to districts that are in disarray. And my gift is to come in and be able to put structures in place to help those strong structures get established, so that the district itself can continue to grow, with a focus on students and supporting teachers." She has experience working with a turnaround district, Webster. She also worked for Mascenic Regional School District in New Hampshire, and was a principal before she rose to Superintendent roles.
"I have a special education background and I started my career as a counselor, and in each of my roles I have been an advocate for kids in terms of making sure that programs are evolving. And I think that's a really important word, evolving, evolving to support the ever-changing needs of all of our students. Sometimes students get lost in the dust because programming hasn't evolved. Sometimes teachers get burned out because they don't have the supports that they need in order to service the multiple needs of the students." Public education has changed a lot, she said. "There are a lot of social emotional and mental health needs in addition to educational needs." She described herself as a "collaborative leader."
Asked what she knew about the Winchendon School District, Dr. Petruno-Goguen she knew it was a turnaround district, was looking for a middle school principal and an elementary school principal, hiring a Director of Special Education, and has "had some turnover" in staff. "I know that turnover impacts culture and turnover impacts morale. People need to feel secure. 'People' meaning not just teachers, but families and parents and students themselves. A sense of safety and security is built on having people that lead and support your kids, through building that trustful relationship," she said.
The relationship between the Superintendent and the School Committee needs to be very clear, she said, with goals outlined. "I do believe that the Superintendent serves as the head leader of building relationships with teachers and supporting principals in their role. There's a lot of turnover in education and people need to feel like someone's listening and that they're being heard...I think the relationship between the School Committee and the Superintendent needs to be transparent. It needs to be open and honest...the School Committee's role is really outlined by three things: hiring a superintendent, approving a budget and setting policies that are followed in the district that help create the culture that you want. A Superintendent's role is the CEO of the organization, anywhere from the budget building to the human resource and personal relationships and building that entry plan for people to come into the district and feel supported. Curriculum and instruction. Applying for grants, managing the facilities. It's a very big role." She added some examples from her past experience.
Asked how she would maintain morale in a time of transition, Dr. Petruno-Goguen emphasized building relationships, listening, and communication. "I have an open door policy," she said. Morale in a district revolves around a strong strategic plan that everyone agrees to fully commit to. It centers on a sense of belonging, built from several "buckets." Establishing safety for everyone; ensuring that the students were engaged and doing most of the thinking and learning in the classrooms; making sure the district was culturally responsive to students from all different cultures and languages. "It is not one person that is going to create the sustainable change in your district. Everyone has to commit to that. Everyone has to commit to whatever those goals are," she said.
Asked how she saw her role in working with the community, Dr. Petruno-Goguen said it was very important for the Superintendent to be a part of the community. She explained that in her previous positions, she was in the school buildings all the time. She participated in "fun events," read to classes, attended the football games, went to all the open houses. She wanted parents to feel they could always talk to her about anything they were concerned about, and that they understood how to get help for their child. "I think as a superintendent, having been in the role of a guidance counselor and a principal, I think you have to model that. So that your principals and your guidance counselors and your people who work underneath you model that openness and willingness to help parents and students find the success that they're looking for."
Dr. Petruno-Goguen said that a School Committee is like a governing board and the Superintendent is the CEO. There needs to be a chain of command for communication, and "it can get very unhealthy when people go directly to a School Committee." She explained, "things can get pretty muddied if School Committees get involved in the day to day without allowing the people who are in the day to day to help to solve the problem. Because there are complex issues that happen on every given day involving kids and students and teachers, and some of that is not for public consumption."
Asked what she saw as the specific mission of an interim (as opposed to the permanent) Superintendent, Dr. Petruno-Goguen said it wasn't her style to "do nothing and just hold the ground still." She would build relationships and keep the district moving toward its goals and on mission. "It is our job to evolve and meet the needs for our kids," she said, and she would want to look at what could be accomplished during her time as interim. She stated that she could probably serve in the position no more than two years, and would be interested in mentoring someone in the district to step into the permanent position.
School Committee members said that the interim would need to "hit the ground running" in the job, and there was some discussion of how soon Dr. Petruno-Goguen would be able to start, as she will be out of the country until August 7.
After Dr. Petruno-Goguen left the Zoom meeting, the School Committee members agreed that she was a very strong candidate. The second Zoom interview, Dr. Marlene DiLeo ( resume ), had quite a lot in common with Dr. Petruno-Goguen in terms of experience and background. She had also been a superintendent for years, in the town of Ware, and previous to that had worked as a principal and teacher in Holyoke. Her base training is in the area of physical education and athletics rather than counseling and Special Education, however.
The first of the in-person interviews was candidate Shauna LaPointe ( resume ) ( LinkedIn ), who is a current employee of the Winchendon Public Schools. Shauna stood out from the other three applicants in several ways; she is a life-long Winchendon resident and graduate of the Winchendon school system, and she has no previous administrative experience. She teaches education courses at Fitchburg State University. But Shauna impressed all listeners very favorably with her dedication to Winchendon and its school system, as well as her knowledgability, positive but realistic attitude, and enthusiasm. Her educational base is in elementary education, grades 1-6, in which she holds a Masters degree.
Before Shauna came forward for her interview, School Committee member David LaPointe addressed concerns he had heard that he had a conflict of interest with the candidate. Ms. LaPointe's husband, Jeremy, works in the LaPointe Law Office building, although David and Jeremy have independent solo law practices. Mr. David LaPointe explained that contrary to rumors, Jeremy is not his son, and there is no blood relationship between him and either Shauna or Jeremy LaPointe. Mr. David LaPointe stated that he had discussed the entire situation with the state Ethics Commission and wanted to say "on pain of perjury and under oath" that there was no relationship or conflict of interest, and there is no connection between himself and Jeremy LaPointe beyond their names. (The Courier will note that there are many families of French Canadian heritage in the region and names like "LaPointe" are extremely common.)
The final interviewee was Roland R. Joyal Jr. ( resume ), who has experience as a Superintendent and Assistant Superintendent in West Springfield and Chicopee, and an educational base in science, having been a vocational high school science teacher in Springfield.
Ms. LaPointe's and Mr. Joyal's interviews may be seen on the town YouTube page. The direct link is www.youtube.com/watch?v=XcJraBVt6ig . The Zoom recording, including the first two interviews with Dr. Petruno-Goguen and Dr. DiLeo, had not been posted to the town YouTube page by press time.
During the public comment period, following Mr. Joyal's interview, two citizens rose to say they wondered why Dr. Forsythe was participating in the interviews as a member of the School Committee (he asked questions and took part in the Committee discussions) when he had publicly announced he was resigning one week earlier. When the vote was being taken, Dr. Forsythe said he would like to respond to those questions. He explained that he had been communicating with Ms. Kast-McBride "to help everything transition smoothly" and he had not yet officially resigned. He had stated he would not participate in the selection of the interim Superintendent "because I think it's important for the new Board to be fully supportive of the new Superintendent." At the same time, he felt it was important for him to be present for the interviews. However, he would be abstaining from the actual vote to decide on a candidate.
There was remarkable agreement among all commenters, both School Committee members and citizens in attendance, about the four candidates. All were most impressed by Dr. Petruno-Goguen, and favorably impressed by Ms. LaPointe but agreed she needs some more experience and training to prepare for the role of superintendent. A motion was made (with a "friendly amendment" to add the usual conditions) to offer Dr. Petruno-Goguen the position, contingent on the successful completion of contract negotiations, and assuring that she was eligible for employment under the regulations of the state retirement system. The Committee voted 3-0-1 to approve the motion, with no nay votes and Dr. Forsythe abstaining.
The Courier asked Ms. Kast-McBride if she could comment on what Superintendent Thad King's current status is, but Ms. Kast-McBride said she was not able to comment.

Comments