DPW Brings Proposal for Replacing Sewer Main from Hyde Park to River Street to BOS

Esta notícia ainda está sendo traduzida; aqui está em inglês.
At their meeting on Monday, April 27, the Board of Selectmen heard a presentation by Department of Public Works Director Patrick Wood and team members from the engineering firm Tighe & Bond about serious issues with the cross-country sewer line running from the area of Hyde Park Drive toward the treatment plant on River Street, and proposals for correcting the problems. The discussion continued at the BOS meeting on May 11.
At the April 27 meeting, Mr. Wood began by explaining that Tighe & Bond had begun a study of the town's sewer system about two years ago. "The study started out with a really comprehensive infiltration and inflow study for our sewer. What that basically means is that we have groundwater coming into our sewer, usually through loose joints, holes, catch basins, we should say, sewer manholes, and it takes up the sewer capacity. That's one negative, but the other negative is that we're actually paying for this, for treating groundwater. So it has a monetary cost and physical cost to it...this was identified as one of the major contributors, talking about the Hyde Park-River Street cross country sewer system, and we've asked Tighe & Bond to come up with some possible alternatives to how we could eliminate that."
Tighe & Bond Project Manager Cassandra LaRochelle and Tighe & Bond team members Elizabeth Olson and Jess DeJesus joined Mr. Wood to give the presentation.
Ms. LaRochelle stated that the current phase of the project will be funded through a Rural Development Fund grant through the state. However, there are potential cost impacts to sewer system users.
Ms. LaRochelle explained that besides wastewater from homes, other inflow gets into the pipes through cracks or joint defects in the pipes, or from heavy rainfall into catch basins. This extra inflow ends up getting treated at the plant. "So there's about 3,000 feet of 6 to 10 inch asbestos and clay sewer mains that travel cross country from the Hyde Park area down to Front Street and then down steep slopes to River Street, where there's the interceptor that actually takes all of the town's flows to the treatment plant. The northern part of the area of that cross country is largely wetlands. It's pretty swampy up there. And as I mentioned, there's very steep slopes on the southern end where it goes from Front to River. And throughout the whole alignment there, the sewer pipes go through the woods and on some portions on private property," she explained. This is the problem area being looked at. She showed some actual photos of the inside of the pipes with water spurting into the pipe through cracks, or roots that had grown into the pipe. "We saw almost 35,000 gallons per day of infiltration, and that's only what we were able to inspect," she said.
Mr. Wood said, "Historically, we've been responding to this area for sewer backups. And just the terrain makes it difficult to fix anything, not to mention that there are wetlands, so anything that we would want to do to get in there would require some permitting, even if it was just temporary. The CCTV information that we were able to gather a few years ago was incomplete because the slopes of those pipes are just too steep, and there's so many structures in between, it's kind of an unknown as well. So eliminating this really would help the amount of calls that we would get for the sewer backups, not just environmentally, but also for our workforce as well. So it's been challenging over the years just this section alone." Ms. DeJesus explained that the project has multiple phases; this is the study phase and then there will be a series of design phases if the town proceeds with the project.
Ms. Olson then began introducing the five alternative solutions. The second least expensive would be replacing the existing asbestos pipe with new, 12-inch PVC pipe, along with replacing manhole covers. This would have a 75-year design life and reduce the infiltration. It would require digging through wetlands, clearing vegetation, construction noise for residents, and a temporary bypass while the new pipe is put in.
The second alternative is putting a liner into the existing pipe, which is sealed in with epoxy resin. It doesn't require digging and is faster to install. It has less impacts to wetlands. The disadvantage is that some pipes may not be in a condition where lining them will work so in those places it might be necessary to dig down for spot repairs. It also doesn't address sewer capacity, and residents who are experiencing frequent sewer backups might still have a persistent problem with those. The issues around the line being difficult to access and maintain will remain.
Ms. DeJesus went on with options three through five. "Alternatives three and four would involve abandoning the cross country sewer and transporting the wastewater from the property served by that sewer via different means," she said. "So these two alternatives are about how to handle that wastewater without the cross country sewer. So alternative three involves abandoning that sewer, capping it on both sides, not using it anymore, and transporting that wastewater through two pump stations with force mains. So we've been calling these the Front Street pump station and the Hyde Park pump station based on their location." Some properties with direct connections to the abandoned line will need to have new connections to other points. Some of the lines could rely on a gravity flow, since they're going downhill. The pumps would operate with electricity so there would be a power cost to the system.
The advantages of option three are reliable service and a system that is easily accessible for maintainance. It also addresses the capacity limitation and allows for the system to expand, without requiring a bypass, and it impacts wetlands far less. It would eliminate the sewer backup problems. The disadvantages are largely in the installation and construction, plus it's the second most costly alternative.
The fourth and most expensive alternative also has considerable impact on residents. Ms. DeJesus explained, "This would involve abandoning the cross country sewer in place and redirecting that flow via low pressure sewers instead of via gravity. So this would involve small diameter pipes installed along the roads and grinder pumps installed at each home and business that is serviced by this area...your lateral would come out and be going to the gravity sewer. So this would redirect that flow into this small sump that contains a grinder pump. As the level would increase, that would trigger the pump to turn on that then macerates the wastewater and sends it out that discharge pipe that is a small diameter, low pressure pipe. So all of the pumps within the system operating are what's pushing the wastewater along, basically small force mains to send the flow upstream. You can see this also involves a level of electrical work within the property, there's a control panel that would need to be installed." Alternative four doesn't have any advantages over alternative three. It's often used where gravity sewers won't work. It's expensive, and it means residents have a big new piece of equipment to operate and maintain.
Alternative five is simply to do nothing at all.
After some more discussion of the pros and cons of alternatives one, two and three, Ms. LaRochelle explained how the project would proceed if the town chose one of the options. They would be looking at a variety of possible funding sources, including the state Clean Water Fund, the EPA and Mass Works. The lifespan of alternative three, with the pump stations, would be 30 to 50 years, possibly longer, Ms. DeJesus said.
The Board decided to consider the information and return to the topic at their meeting on Monday, May 11. At the BOS meeting on Monday, May 11, Mr. Wood came before the board to discuss the options. Mr. Wood said, "I think what we really wanted to stress was that option number three was our preferred alternative, which would include two new sewer pump stations, one was going to be on River Street" and the other at Front Street and Hyde Park. He went on, "What we would like to do is to have Tighe & Bond continue their design efforts up through 50 percent design which is being covered under a grant, and that will get us to the point where we have a pretty solid understanding of what the existing conditions are and what is feasible. Assuming that this option is going to be feasible, we'll also have a really good opinion of probable cost that we can take and start looking at what other grants and funding is available, and when we could actually get this slated for construction somewhere down the line."
Board Chair Andrew Beauvais had some questions about the types of grants that could be applied for going forward, and whether there might be conflicts with the Glenallen Street sewer extension that is being considered. Mr. Beauvais also asked how the estimated cost of $4.6 million for option three was arrived at so early in the process. Ms. DeJesus, who was joining the meeting remotely, explained that they were making a conservative estimate (that means overestimating to allow for the worser case scenarios in terms of what might be encountered in construction) based on what they knew so far and what could be under the surface (a lot of ledge, for example).
Board member Melissa Blanchard brought up the veterans' housing which will be tying into the system in that area, and whether there will be enough capacity. Mr. Wood said that capacity will be considered in this design phase.
The Board was basically in agreement that options one, four and five (replacing the pipe, requiring individual pumps at every user's location and doing nothing) were off the table, leaving two and three (line the existing pipe or abandon it and put in pump stations). There was discussion about getting public input and holding a public hearing, with Tighe & Bond present to answer technical questions. Board member Erika Eitland argued that it was important to get the process moving as soon as possible, since they were dropping option four that involved a direct cost to each user.
The Board voted "to approve alternative three to move forward to the 50 percent completion of construction documents by Tighe & Bond and overseen by Department of Public Works."
For those who would like to review all the details of the project, the presentations and other documents are on the DPW's web page at www.townofwinchendon.com/616/Hyde-Park-to-River-Street-Cross-Country- .
The presentation and discussion at the April 27 Board meeting may be viewed on WinchendonTV at winchendon.cablecast.tv/internetchannel/show/378?site=1 . The discussion starts at 0:19:48 in the video.
The discussion at the May 11 Board meeting may be viewed on WinchendonTV at winchendon.cablecast.tv/internetchannel/show/386?site=1 . The discussion starts at 1:17:00 in the video.
A name wrong in this story? Tell us
A figure wrong in this story? Tell us
Know someone in the picture? Sign in to tell the editors — no password, a link by email.

Comments